It's sort of hard to say anything knowledgeable about / recommend a piece of kit unless you've got some personal experience with it.
And I won't recommend the stuff I've had poor experiences with...
/ Karl
I`ve used all different types of tents in all situations from the jungles to mtns to the artic,every one is different,it`s important to remember your poor experiances may be different to another,example you may buy a tent and being larger than average may find it cramped,then not recommending the tent on that bases,while MR b buys the same tent being 5`4" finds it a palace,same to the opposite with weight.YOU must look at what you intend to use the tent for,if it`s four season,2man ,4 man,base camp,altitude,desert ,we can go on .the tent we would not recomend from a bad experiance may be perfect for hi needs.