Login

Partners

Bushcraft Ventures 
Bushcraft Expeditions 
Greenman Bushcraft 
Wildside Survival 
Woodcraft School 
Woodsmoke 
 
Karrimor Dry bag Print E-mail
Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Information
Manufacturer: PRI

Product name:
Dry bag 90 or 40

Fabric: polyurethane (PU) coated nylon

RRP: £50

These dry bags are designed to go inside a rucksack. There are two sizes available: 40 and 90 litre.

For our trial of the bags, we chose the large version for a smaller bag (Sabre 45 and a 40 litre Snugpak Rocketpak).  We were going with the theory that, if required to cross rivers, the contents plus the rucksack could be placed into the bag and used as a dry, floatation system - Thankfully we didn’t need to test this theory! The dry bag sat nicely in the bottom of the rucksacks and, as there are no valves or anything complicated to remember, the closer system was relatively easy to operate – there was, however, some technique to master with the squeezing out of the air.

Karrimor Dry bag /rucksack liner
Made from olive green polyurethane coated nylon material with taped seams, a roll top and snap closure fittings, the bag seems impressive and indeed, whilst testing in the real, harsh environment of the jungle, the bag did a very good job of keeping the rucksack contents dry despite multiple dunkings in the river and other general abuse. Despite the outside becoming wet, the contents were always bone dry.

Back in the UK, I decided to test the bag some more and filled the bag with water, placed it upright in the bath then, after a few minuets, turned it over to test the roll top.  Surprisingly, within only a couple of minutes one of the tape seams leaked and there were a couple of pin prick holes in the actual material as well. The holes may well have been made by the abuse the bag received in the jungle so I wasn’t too worried about those but the failure of the seam certainly concerned me. However, I’m sure that an application of seam sealer would have solved both problems but I would have hoped that the seams held better in the first instance.
As expected the roll over top with snap fastening did eventually leak but, again, this took a lot longer and only allowed a small amount of water through.
 
Conclusion:
Apart from the ‘fault’ with the seam, I liked this bag a lot - The design and operation were simple and the end result worked extremely well. Of course, it’s always advisable to test all your kit before any trip and, if I had taken my own advice, I would have been able to seal the seam before venturing out and the bag would have been perfectly waterproof.  Perhaps I was expecting a little too much from the bag, being designed as much for the military as the civilian market, and would have thought the design to be more robust.

 

Reviewed by Mark Aspell

Comments (0)add
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 

Latest Reviews

Snugpak Rocketpak (08.05.2008)

The rucksack is designed to be worn over military belt pouches, which means it rides high on the back. The belt is in actually fact a waist belt rather than a hip belt and fits around the waist.

Karrimor Dry bag (06.05.2008)

Thankfully we didn’t need to test this theory! The dry bag sat nicely in the bottom of the rucksacks and, as there are no valves or anything complicated to remember...

Leatherman Vista Hunting Multi-tool (28.04.2008)

John Fenna reviews the Leatherman Vista Multi-tool: Made to the same high standards that have made Leatherman Tools world famous, the Vista is very well engineered, the shears being ultra sharp and having an extra wide opening to the smoothly closing jaws for tackling thicker wood.

Fjallraven: Vintage 20 (19.04.2008)
thumb_vintage20s.jpgThe main body of the Vintage 20, the lid and side pockets are made from Fjallraven’s famous impregnated 65/35% polycotton G1000
Magfire: Fire Starter Tinder (17.04.2008)
thumb_magfiretinder2.jpgI do not know if others have tried this product, but when your kit is too wet for friction firelighting, there is no silver birch around and your cotton wool is wet, this is a sure fire way to get a fire going
Fjällraven Greenland Trousers (01.04.2008)
fjallravengreentrousers6.jpgRay Mears has a Midas touch - of that, there’s no doubt. The Fjällraven Forester trousers, advertised by Woodlore et al, have shot off the shelves

Most Popular Reviews

Fallkniven F1 knife (05.04.2007)
thumb_f11.JPG The F1 is a basic fixed blade knife with a 'drop-point' 3.5inch blade (made of VG 10 stainless steel) and a man-made (Thermorun) handle. Originally designed for use by Aircrew of the Swedish Defence Forces as a survival knife, as any survivor will tell you a 'survival-knife' is the one you have with you at the time, so the F1 is designed to be small & light enough to be carried at all times but robust enough to withstand the abuse it would encounter in a survival situation within the Arctic Circle...
Bushman UK Knives (23.03.2007)
thumb_bushman_pair_1.jpgI rate these knifes very highly. Both in design and construction
Maxpedition Jumbo Versipack Review (03.07.2007)
thumb_Overview Bag.JPGI was intrigued by Spamel’s thread on the Snugpak Response Pak – or their other types of ‘grab-n-go’ bags - and what people carried in them. I’m a bit of a bag junkie, partly because of my work (military) and partly because of a quest to be able to carry the right equipment for the right job in practically any situation.  I guess the ‘Holy Grail’ is effectively a bag that you instinctively grab, without thinking about it, before you go off for an adventure.
Karrimor Sabre 45 Rucksack (12.12.2007)

thumb_saber45front.jpg

Sabre 45 is probably the rucksack that others are marked against in the bushcraft market. I was very interested to see what all the hype was about and if the real thing lived up to it all!

Fire Steel (23.03.2007)
thumb_steelmain.jpgThe sparks that come off the steel, burn longer and hotter than anything I have used before. Sometimes they can sizzle away at 3000 degrees centigrade for a second or more,
BCB Crusader Mess TIn with Lid (05.07.2007)
thumb_crusadermesstin1.jpgThe mess tin is a solid stainless steel and relatively lightweight cooking vessel. It comes with a well fitting lid, which is a bonus compared with the old aluminium version which came without a lid. It saves precious fuel and makes your water (or whatever you are preparing in it) come to a boil significantly faster.